Before going deep into the difference between belief & knowledge or discussing issues of ethics and morality, we should first and foremost be able to differentiate between existence and non-existence.
Perception is "King"
With our senses as our only interface between our minds and the external reality, we can quickly realize that perception is "king". Our ability to perceive is the ultimate limiting factor.
For this discussion, we can ignore certain questions about the ultimate nature of reality. Philosophical questions such as: "Are we living in a matrix?" or "What if we are just brains in jars?" could be said to be irrelevant. For one, the limits of our perception would prevent us from ever addressing such questions. Secondly, in either scenario, we would still have this perceived reality to deal with.
Existence and Manifestation
The single defining criteria for differentiating existence from non-existence is manifestation. When something manifest itself (and thus we can preceive that manifestation), we would say that that something exist.
Simply put, something is said to exist if we can preceive of its manifestation.
Manifestations may be directly observable or indirectly observed. For example: light is visually observable directly; solid objects can be directly detected by one or more of our senses; gravity can be observed by observing/measuring its effects on matter, etc.
Objections?
Some may have objections to how existence is defined here.
For example, what about non-manifesting existent objects? Well, it is possible that such objects exist. However, what does it mean to say that such an object "exist"? Firstly, how do you determine that such an object is in existence? If it does not manifest, what criteria are you using to verify its existence? How do we differentiate non-manifesting-existent objects from non-existent-(and therefore, does not manifest) objects? My answer: there is no criteria to differentiate and thus meaningless to say that any non-manifesting entity "exist". In calling such objects "existent", we effectively castrate the word "exist".
What about manifesting objects that we have not had perception (observation) of? This one is simple. That answer would be "we don't know yet". The same criteria applies. If we had not had verifiable observation of the object in question, whatever would it mean to say that it exist?
Acquring knowledge of existence
To correctly acquire knowledge of the existence of entities/effects/etc (therefore, external reality), we must also understand the ability of our senses. We need to realize the limits of perception and how we may be able to improve/support them.
The Scientific Method comes to mind. The methodology of science eliminates error and bias by design. It holds practitioners of science to the highest evidentiary standards - requiring that they produce evidence for their hypothesis that is demonstrable and verifiable with sound and valid arguments. To date, the Scientific Method is the single most reliable method that humanity has to differentiate fact from opinion.
Through science, we have realize the limits of our senses. And has since devised various instruments to assist our senses in our pursuit for knowledge. Instruments such as telescopes, microscopes, spectrometers, spectogram, voltmeters and etc.
We also learnt of the errors our senses are prone of making and how reliable they are. And thus made efforts to rectify or avoid such errors that may arise. For example, we understand that eyewitness accounts, though helpful, is prone to various faults and thus is one of the weaker forms of evidence. Another example would be realizing the importance of collaboration in making observations.
In conclusion...
We can conclude that for factual matters concerning the state of existence, we can reliably utilize the Scientific Method (which is, in a sense, our boosted senses) to detect manifestations to establish the existence of entities or phenomenons.
Given the above discussion, questions about existence is clear cut. If we do not have evidence (that withstands the standards of science) of manifestation, we do not have the "right" to claim existence. In such cases where evidence is lacking, claiming existence is meaningless. It usually demonstrates a lack of integrity or of understanding or even both on the part of the claimant. The correct answer would be "we don't know".
The diametrical answer that claims "X does not exist" in same scenario would also be logically untenable if the claim is absolute. Such a claim in common language would be fine for most intents and purposes. Note that absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.
Labels: Articles , Philosophy
Here's a compilation of the my more lengthy entries that discusses specific topics. This page is linked on the shortcuts at the top of my blog and will be updated when I have more essays to add.
About Me
Stuff pertaining to me or my blog
My Route to Atheism
The story of my not-particularly-interesting route (since I was never really religious) to finding my atheism.
Youtube Channel - Atheozoa
This page lists the various playlists I've managed to compile on Youtube relating to matters of religion, atheism, science, evolution and etc.
My Atheism
Essays about my atheism - Why I don't believe in god
Scripture as poor evidence
Discusses some reasons for not accepting scripture as evidence (particularly the bible).
Ugarit and the Abrahamic Faiths
A look at the origins of Yahweh, the god behind the abrahamic faiths, and how that cast doubts on them.
Yahweh, the morally inferior god
This article takes a look specifically at Yahweh and why is cannot be the moral authority that he is said to be.
Abiogenesis, Life and Gods
Here's a short essay of the issue between abiogenesis and creationism.
Science and the Incredulous
Another short article about the problem science has with the general public and the religious.
Evolution and its denial
Putting forth some of the evidence for evolution, its predictions & applications and its denial by some of the theistic factions.
Human Morality
The objections to the Argument from Morality.
Universe Vs God
Pointing out the special pleading in the First Cause Argument.
Fine Tuned Universe
A discussion of some of the objections to the fine-tuning argument and anthropic principle.
Other Stuff
Some things that don't have a category just yet.
Atheism and Agnosticism
The distinction between Atheism/Theism and Agnosticism/Gnosticism. Plus a brief clarification of some common misconceptions of what Atheism/Atheist is.
Evidence Vs Creationism
Here's 4 groups of evidence that doesn't quite mesh with Creationism: Atavism, Pseudogenes, ERVs and the Geological Record.
On Existence
My thoughts on Existence, Manifestation and Evidence. This is representative of my stance on what it means to me to say that "X exist" - This is also related to my atheism.
Last updated: 10 May 2009
Theism and Atheism, Gnosticism and Agnosticism
Theism is the belief in the existence of god(s). Simply put, a theist is a person who has accepted the proposition "God exist."
Atheism is the rejection of theism. That is, an atheist is a person who rejects the proposition "God exist." Note that it is simply a rejection of theism - It does not necessarily mean that an atheist accepts the opposing proposition that "God does not exist."
This distinction is made by weak atheism and strong atheism. Weak atheism is only the rejection of theism. Strong atheism not only rejects theism but accepts the proposition "God does not exist" as well.
That's theism and atheism - These deal with beliefs.
Check out the Wikipedia articles on Theism and Atheism.
Agnosticism deals with knowledge. A gnostic has knowledge of the existence of god(s). An agnostic does not have such knowledge.
Theist/Atheist and Gnostic/Agnostic classification thus creates 4 different categories. To learn about the distinction check out the Iron Chariots Wiki: Atheist vs Agnosticism.
What about me?
I am an agnostic atheist.
I have no knowledge of the existence of a god or gods. I reject theism for there is no evidence to warrant belief in a god.
Belief require evidence. This is necessarily true - otherwise we would be believing in all sorts of things if evidence is not the criteria for belief in matters of fact. Without evidence, belief is not warranted and is irrational. Thus, non-belief is the rational and default position.
To learn about my position, see my entry: Why I don't believe.
Common misconceptions
The following are some of the common misconception/misrepresentation of atheists along with my responses.
Atheists say that "god does not exist." Prove it!
False, on two counts.
Atheism, in its broadest sense, is simply the rejection of theism. Asserting that "god does not exist" is strong atheism which is a subset (and minority) of atheists.
Having clarified that most atheists are weak atheists, it is notable that the burden of proof lies on the theists. The theist who makes the claim should back up his claim with evidence. If others rejects his claim, they are correct and is not required to produce evidence of the contrary (especially if they are not asserting god does not exist).
In fact, rational atheists (atheists who are rationalists/naturalists) are not strong atheists (in most of the common definitions of god).
Atheists believe in the Big Bang and Evolution. They think we came from nothing.
Firstly, atheism does not necessitate the belief in the Big Bang theory and the theory of evolution.
Secondly, scientific theories does not require belief (faith) in the religious sense. Scientific theories are accepted based on the evidence and the knowledge/trust in the integrity of the scientific community. This applies to most rational atheists.
Third. Believing "we came from nothing" is a misconception of the Big Bang theory.
If god didn't create the universe then there is no purpose to the universe. So if there's no purpose in life, why don't atheists just kill themselves.
Purpose need not be intrinsic to the universe. However it does not follow that we should commit suicide. Rational atheists typically do not believe in gods or afterlife. As a result, we think that this is the one and only shot at life we have and thus we treasure our lives.
I think a quote from Richard Dawkins, in his book "Unweaving the Rainbow", can shed some light on this point:
“After sleeping through a hundred million centuries we have finally opened our eyes on a sumptuous planet, sparkling with colour, bountiful with life. Within decades we must close our eyes again. Isn't it a noble, an enlightened way of spending our brief time in the sun, to work at understanding the universe and how we have come to wake up in it? This is how I answer when I am asked -- as I am surprisingly often -- why I bother to get up in the mornings. To put it the other way round, isn't it sad to go to your grave without ever wondering why you were born? Who, with such a thought, would not spring from bed, eager to resume discovering the world and rejoicing to be a part of it?”
It's obvious that god created the universe.
No. It is only obvious if you're brainwashed into theism. If not, you have fundamentally flawed understanding of the scientific method or a poor understanding of science in general.
Atheists are immoral or have no reason to be moral because they don't believe in god.
Obviously false. I've addressed this in a previous entry: Human Morality.
Any more common slanders?
The Cosmological argument; The First Cause argument.
It goes something like this.
1. Everything has a cause.
2. Nothing can cause itself.
3. A causal chain cannot be of infinite length.
4. Therefore, a First Cause (the Uncaused Cause) must exist.
1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause.
2. The Universe began to exist.
3. Therefore, the Universe had a cause.
4. That cause, we call god.
That cause, we call foul - That's Special Pleading
The objection is this: If the premise is "everything must have a cause" and yet the conclusion is "There is something that does not have a cause," the argument just contradicted itself.
And why specifically that the universe must have a cause but yet god doesn't need one? Where's difference? Why the exemption from the rule? That's Special Pleading.
In addition, we actually have evidence of the Universe existing. In light of the evidence, our beliefs should only go that far - We've no evidence of god.
And even if we concede that point that god is indeed the first cause, his identity is still non-specific. Is he/she/they/it even one of the theistic gods?
The Iron Chariots Wiki - Uncaused Cause
Big Bang and the Big Misconception
One absolutely moronic claim made by some theists is: Atheists believe that everything came from nothing. False.
This retarded claim most likely stem from a misconception of what the Big Bang Theory states. And since most rational atheists accept scientific discoveries, the misconception is heaped onto us.
The Big Bang theory does not state that the nothing exploded and thus the universe is born. The theory states that, based on current evidence, tracing back in time, there was a time when everything was compressed into a tiny, dense singularity. This singularity expanded rapidly and gave rise to the current state of our universe.
Nowhere does it mention that there was nothing. Current evidence ends at the singularity. Whether this singularity was created or not is unknown, it is ludicrous to assert that one is case when there are more possibilities than those.
Oh...
As part of my usual video whoring habit, I'd recommend this series by Potholer54 - From Big Bang to Us - Made Easy
Labels: Arguments , Articles , Atheism , Creationism , Science
A frequent accusation from theists is that atheists cannot be moral because they don't believe in god. This stems from the concept that god is the author of morality and thus the two are intrinsically tied.
Another similar (but more condescending) accusation acknowledges that most atheists are moral but claims that atheists have no basis for morality. Again, this stems from the theistic concept that morality is based on god.
Thus, the Argument from Morality. And I think that the entire concept is flawed.
Euthyphro Dilemma
The problem with god as the moral authority is condensed into the following question:
Is that which is good commanded by God because it is good,
or is it good because God commands it?
In the former, god essentially has nothing to do with morality. If an action is morally correct, god, being good, commands it. If an action is morally incorrect, god will not command it. As such, god is simply being a messenger. He does not set the moral standards - he merely following them. If this is the case, morality has nothing to do with a belief in god. One can be moral if they investigated the principles behind them.
In the latter, god dictates morality. He is free to decide what is good or bad - there is no standards to adhere to. As such, morality dictated by god would be arbitrary.
Hypothetically, god could have easily commanded that rape or murder is morally correct. At this point, theists jump to their deity's defense by claiming that "God is righteous/good and will not command like such." Really? The god of the old testament did command rape and murder. In fact, he also set laws for slavery. Are they then morally correct?
If one acknowledges that rape, murder and slavery are morally incorrect, that would seem to go against the old testament account of this "righteous/good" god. If this is the case, isn't this judgment made based on some other standard that is not the bible? Which brings us to the conclusion in the former question in the dilemma.
See the Iron Chariots Wiki - Euthyphro Dilemma.
Morals from an evolutionary perspective
Before I continue, I should clarify a frequent misunderstanding about evolution and morality. Science and the Theory of Evolution makes no claims on what is moral. The consequences of Social Darwinism is frequently heaped onto the theory as if they were related. They are not.
Explaining how stuff works does not dictate how we should act. The theory of gravity says that jumping off a building will result in falling to your death but it does not imply that we should all throw ourselves off buildings. Same with the theory of evolution - Survival of the fittest does not imply we should kill weak people (and even this is a misunderstanding of the theory).
Using the theory of evolution, the emergence of basic rules in morality can be explained. For example, animals in general do not run around committing murder.
Think of two hypothetical tribes of animals - One with no desire to commit murder and the other with an inclination to murder another tribes mate. Naturally, the tribe with the inclination to kill its members will decline rapidly. Organisms that show no inclination to kill its own species will stay alive to propagate.
That's just a simplistic example. For more complex concepts such as how altruism may arise by evolution, I'd recommend The Selfish Gene by Richard Dawkins.
Empathy and Rationality
One does not require a god to dictate morality. We have the tools to understand morality and to act morally. They are essentially empathy and rationality. A bit of "heart" and a bit of brains is pretty much all you need to start investigating moral issues.
While atheists are sometimes accused of having no reason to be moral, it seems that the position that theists hold is even shakier when we dig deep into that claim. In essence, such theists are saying that god is the only reason to be moral. If they ever knew for a fact that god does not exist, nothing would stop them from committing crimes. And if that is the case, I'm glad they go to church or [Insert place of worship].
Apart from god, one of the most powerful reason to be moral is our empathy. Apply the Golden Rule - Just ask yourself: Would like having your stuff stolen? Would like to be murdered? Would you like to be raped? Etc. I am sure most of us would prefer to keep our stuff, stay alive and not be raped. It does not take a lot of reasoning to realize that everyone should act morally for everyone's sake.
Law and Morality
Today's secular laws safeguard the survival and orderliness of the society so as long as they are enforced. Apart from representing the moral stance of its people, laws also ensure the smooth flow of daily activities, prevent abuse and etc.
In essence, the laws of a society are simply the rules that the people of the society agreed to live by. This would be how those laws came into being in the first place.
To establish a cohesive society, its people must agree with the rules. These rules embody the morality of its people. As beings with empathy and reason, these rules would include that which is moral. If, for example, an individual disagrees and believes murder is moral, the society as a whole would disagree and remove that individual should he commit the crime. The logic behind this is the basis for our laws, enforcers and prisons.
One last thing
An unusual claim by theists is that even non believers are moral because god "placed his moral laws in our hearts." This can be disputed on several levels. The Euthyphro Dilemma still applies. The fact that, for example, even christians do not adhere to the 613 commandments in their bible disputes the claim (there's a defense to this objection - but it fails as well).
I for one do not and will not adhere to the "morality" of the old testament god - he's utterly disgusting.
I'd recommend this series by holysinecure which questions biblical morality
Labels: Arguments , Articles , Atheism , Christianity , Morality , Videos (Religion)
Fact AND Theory?
One of the common misunderstandings that people have with evolution is semantics. There's no error here - Evolution is both a fact and a theory.
The fact that is evolution refers to the phenomenon of evolution - The change in frequency of alleles within a gene pool from one generation to the next, ie; descent with modification. This has been observed both in nature as well as in the laboratories.
The Theory of Evolution seeks to explain the Fact of Evolution. In Science, a theory is a comprehensive framework for describing, explaining and making falsifiable predictions about related sets of phenomena based on rigorous observation, experimentation and logic. Saying "Evolution is just a theory" reveals a fundamental misunderstanding of what science is about.
The Evidence
Evolution is described as the unifying theory in biology. Different scientific disciplines all point to same conclusion: Evolution. Various lines of evidence that include: Genetics, Phylogenetics, Paleontology, Morphology, Embryology, Molecular & Cellular biology etc.
The overwhelming amount of evidence for evolution cannot be described within a single blog entry. I'd suggest visiting the list of playlists that I've compiled: Here.
To learn about the evidence for common descent - See this article: 29+ Evidence for Macroevolution
If you're interested in Transitional Forms, read this article - Transitional Vertebrate Fossils or try these videos:
► Evolution is REAL Science #4 and #5
► 9th Foundational Falsehood of Creationism
What about Phylogenetics and nested hierarchies:
► 10th Foundational Falsehood of Creationism
► Nested Hierarchies
On Speciation, check out:
► 11th Foundational Falsehood of Creationism
► How Evolution Works 7 - Part 1 & Part 2
Here are some simple and frequently used examples of evidence for evolution:
► Human Chromosome 2 Fusion
► Our faulty Vitamin C gene
► Endogenous Retroviruses, ERV
Scientific Predictions
As with any scientific theories, the Theory of Evolution is capable of making predictions. One of the most spectacular prediction was the finding of Tiktaalik. Using the theory, researchers predicted the type of features Tiktaalik is expected to have, where it could be found and the age of the rocks it should be found in.
Check out this presentation by Neil Shubin, author of Your Inner Fish (Tiktaalik): Introducing Tiktaalik, Your Inner Fish Part 1 and Part 2.
On accurate predictions by the Theory of Evolution, see: How Evolution is Scientific - Part 2
Numerous other fossils that were found confirm the predictions made by the theory. For a list of them, see: Evolution is REAL Science #5
Modern Applications
Something that most people don't realize is that the theory of evolution is being used in our daily lives. I've heard ridiculous remarks like: "Gravity is real, it affects me daily. But evolution have nothing to do with me at all...... blah blah, evolution is not true."
The theory of evolution is utilized in the realm of medicine. Certain actions we take with regards to antibiotics is because of our understanding of evolution. Our handling of HIV and genetic diseases has also been enhanced by our understanding of evolution. Heck, the theory is even involved in agriculture and conservation efforts.
I'd recommend browsing through these: How does evolution impact my life?
Overwhelming Arrogance Vs Overwhelming Evidence
People deny the theory of evolution even before getting acquainted with the evidence are morons. It's simply irrational - How does one declare something to be false without even knowing what it is about.
In spite of the evidence, yet without learning about them, we have creationist sheeps and shepherds running around propagating lies about evolution.
That is ARROGANT.
All too frequently, atheists and scientists are the ones being slammed with the label "arrogant" for being "know-it-all's." We've seen the evidence, understood the theory and knew of its implications. When we make the claim "God did not create the lifeforms as we know them", it isn't an atheistic assertion. It's a fact - Evolution occurred.
Excuse me. Look in the mirror. Evolution deniers are the ones being arrogant. Who are you to claim that all those scientists who spent years on scientific education and working in their respective fields are wrong? Who are you say the theory is false when you haven't had the littlest clue of what the theory is? Who are you to deny the works of all those scientists when you don't even know the mountains of evidence and literature behind the theory?
That would be the height of intellectual arrogance. This might be simply because of the Skewed views of Science or worst, wilful ignorance with an intent of deceit.
The Argument from Personal Incredulity.
By the way, incredulity is defined by the dictionary as:
in⋅cre⋅du⋅li⋅ty [in-kri-doo-li-tee]
–noun
the quality or state of being incredulous; inability or unwillingness to believe.
The inability or unwillingness to believe is highlighted in the following typical responses.
"If humans came from apes, why are there still apes around?"
"It's silly to believe that nothing exploded and then we came into existence."
If you've learnt about the Big Bang theory and the Theory of Evolution, you would have already noticed the misconceptions and errors in thinking exhibited by those statements.
Skewed Views of Science
Science is seriously misunderstood by the general public. In general, these are the types of errors in perceptions:
► Science provides absolute truths.
► Science always changes; we shouldn't trust it.
► Science is just another belief system.
I'd highly recommend watching this video:
Rejection before Comprehension
This is the fate of the Theory of Evolution in the minds of religious sheeps. Even before being acquainted with the theory and its supporting evidence, it is rejected on the basis of religious dogma. That is tragic.
Having seen the responses by theists who reject evolution, one thing is very clear - They haven't got a clue what Evolution is (See my previous post - The Gems of Creationism). Often, they are fed caricatures of evolution by their own churches. Lies to propagate more lies.
If you find that you are rejecting scientific theories even before you understood them, something is seriously wrong. No established theories is without evidence.
Have you ever asked yourself - "Why am I rejecting this when the scientific community accept it as true?" A scientist isn't some bugger down the street who pulls theories out of their asses. They are trained professionals who studied the field in which they are in for years. They have seen the evidence. They have learnt the theories and the rationale behind them.
How are you rationally justified in rejecting their theories without even learning about them in the first place?
Our inability to understand the theories does not mean that the theories are false. That would be faulty logic.
Labels: Arguments , Articles , Atheism , Creationism , Science
A frequent and unusual question that believers tend to bring up when "proving" god is on the origins of life.
"How do you think we were created?"
"I don't believe we arose by chance."
Frankly, I think this sort of questions is kinda redundant when discussing the existence of god. I'll explain...
Abiogenesis
Abiogenesis is the process and the study of how life arose from inanimate matter. Some may find the idea itself implausible, citing that it is impossible for non-life to create life. Bullshit. If you know what life is, you would realize that organisms are essentially a unique arrangement of chemicals and chemical reactions.
Abiogenesis is still in its early stages - There isn't any established theories yet. Right now, there are several competing hypotheses and research is still under way. One such hypothesis is the RNA World Hypothesis.
At this moment in time, Science do not have the complete answer to the origins of life. All we know is this: It is possible that inanimate matter produce life but we don't know exactly how.
Destroying the False Dichotomy
At this moment, some theists may jump and say "AH HA! You don't know how life arose! Obviously, God did it."
To which I reply, Moron.
Not understanding the origin of life does not automatically imply it had to be god. That would be a false dichotomy.
Besides, god is the massive non-answer. If god is defined as the creator of life and life exist, thus the conclusion is god did it - You've just engaged in circular reasoning.
Here's a video that makes the point:
The thing that made the things for which there is no known maker.
Let me say this here. If tomorrow, all the scientists say that all their hypotheses on abiogenesis are wrong, it still does not mean that god did it. The correct response would be I don't know.
Saying "I don't know"
If there is an unexplained phenomenon, it does not imply that cause must be supernatural. The unexplained is simply the unexplained. However improbable or counter-intuitive anything is, it does not require us to jump straight for a supernatural. That is unwarranted and irrational.
Indeed, it may be uncomfortable to not know how life arose or why the universe exist, but such gaps in our knowledge does not grant us the right to attribute it to god. But there is people who do that and hence the term: The God of the Gaps.
Such actions are not harmless, they are actively harmful. If one accepted the god of the gaps as the answer, one stops any attempts to seek the truth.
"I don't know" is not that hard to say - It's an honest response.
Science and Progress in Knowledge
Unusually, some people see "We don't know yet" as a weakness of Science. They are too used to receiving dogmas that assert absolute certainty without evidence.
Science is an active search for truth. It gathers evidence and create hypotheses. It test those hypothesis and when they withstood scrutiny, they are established as theories. The Scientific method is the best tool humanity has to distinguish fact from fantasy.
As an active search for truth, it doesn't have all the answer yet. And the scientific community is simply being honest when it says "We don't know". Compare this with dogmatic baseless assertions that religions make in spite being contradicted in several instances, I'll pick science any day.
Related video: Science, it works!
The 3 Abrahamic faiths: Judaism, Christianity and Islam have at least one thing in common - They trace themselves back to their patriarch, Abraham. So technically, those three religions are worshiping the same god, that is Yahweh, but they have different doctrines about everything else. Although Christianity have the (illogical) concept of the Trinity, all three religions identify themselves as monotheistic - There is only one true god.
So did Yahweh, the alleged creator god, find Abraham one day to begin a succession of events that led to the establishment of religions that regard him as the one and only god? Not that simple.
Ugarit, El and Yahweh
It seems that Yahweh didn't just appear from nowhere. He had to be created somewhere first. And that is the Ugarit religion which predates Judaism.
The Ugarit Yahweh is not some coincidence. There is various aspects that point to the Ugarit religion as being the origins of the Old Testament myths. For example, Ugarit and Israel shared a common literary and linguisitc lineage. Difficult Hebrew words become easier to translate in light of Ugarit texts.
In the bible, it is thought that the words "El" and "Elohim" both refer to Yahweh. However, the discovery of the Ugarit text enhanced our understanding of the old testament text.
Guess what?
Yahweh isn't the creator god in Ugarit. He is just one of sons of the creator god, El. El is a proper name and he is the chief of the Ugarit pantheon. El is refered to as the Creator. The Elohim refers to El's pantheon. Yahweh also has a consort, a goddess, named Asherah.
Ugarit eventually declined but Yahweh was not lost. He was adopted by early Judaism. The religion transformed from polytheistic, to henotheistic and then to monotheistic, Yahweh assimilated El and his characteristics. Much like Horus and Ra in Egyptian religion.
What does this mean?
Sure, this alone does not prove or disprove god. That isn't the point here.
The point is this: The fact Yahweh had such a history cast serious doubts on the monotheistic concept. It questions how much fact there is to the religion - Is Yahweh another arbitrary thing like every other religion on Earth? It seems extremely suspicious that it is human beings who arbitrarily decide how may gods there is and who they are. If god was real, shouldn't it be the other way round?
This probably isn't an argument against gods in general. But it brings up a serious question about the Abrahamic faiths: Why does the alleged one true god have such an unusual history, one that doesn't recognize him to be even at least the top god?
Ugarit and the bible
► Summary of the topic on the Atheist Experience blog
► Theology article about the topic
Atheist Experience episodes about this
► Episode #464
► Episode #466
► Episode #483
Labels: Arguments , Articles , Atheism , Christianity , History
Scripture as evidence?
Uh, no.
Written or inspired by god?
Firstly, scriptures are all written by Man. If you think god(s) wrote any of them personally, please go read up some history. Claims that they were inspired by god are unverifiable because (1) inspiration is subjective and (2) they are dead now, no one can check.
Like I said previously on the opening post to this series, evidence for god would be evidence of god manifesting. Scripture is poor evidence for any god simply because it is not necessarily the product of god.
This applies to all religions.
Since I have a tad bit more knowledge about the bible, I'll use it as the example.
The holy book of inconclusive authorship
If you still haven't realized, the bible is a collection of books. And for most parts, the authors are unknown.
For example, none of the old testament was written by Moses himself. They were likely to be at best hearsay written decades after the fact. Is hearsay reliable? After so many years, wouldn't embellishments inevitably occur?
Neither was the New Testament written by Jesus' actual disciples. The four gospels named after Jesus' disciples were written some 100-150 years after Jesus and his disciples were dead. They are second hand accounts. Where's the reliability in that?
What about the embellishments?
(Even it may adhere to the themes of the bible, is it still not an embellishment?)
If the bible is reliable, would you believe that claims of UFO abduction as well? After all, the claimants are alive and are first-hand accounts.
"Scientific" verses as proof of divinity
Seriously, no.
For every scientific truth in the bible, there is a couple of unscientific lie to complement. That is not proof of omniscient. If you're going to keep the hits and ignore the misses, you're cherrypicking your own damn holy book (big book of MCQ, eh?).
I've given an answer to such an argument previously, so I shall quote myself here:
Verses "hinting" scientific knowledge? Frankly, they are usually distorted or required extremely vague interpretations in order for the verse to make sense scientifically. Such "interpretations" have been done several times over by the devout looking for some anchor in reality for their beliefs. Just search Quranic science on Youtube and you probably get a dozen or more "examples".
For any verse to convince anyone that it hints scientific knowledge, it needs to be flat out obvious to anyone who reads it. And when I say scientific knowledge, I mean something big like a theory rather than a simple fact. Stuff like the "Earth is round" is barely substantial and hardly convincing. If a holy book have an entire chapter dedicated to the Atomic Theory, that would be convincing. However, I may not convert right away, more evidence would be required for a skeptic like me.
Not to mention, such bible science or quran science are usually made AFTER science itself have made the discovery. It is an dishonest attempt to frame the discovery to appear as though the "gods" got there first. It would be much more convincing if it was the holy books which prompted a research in science as opposed to framing the discovery as a religious idea after all the research was done.
However, that being said, evidence of god himself would be more convincing as opposed to hints of scientific knowledge in a 2000 year old book.
[Click here for original post]
[Take a look here (#699 & 700) if you're interested in some of the verses I've had to deal with]
Historicity Vs Divinity
Evidence that the events in the bible took place is not proof of god. Not even close.
First and foremost, let's deal with the old and ridiculous argument that goes: "The places in the bible are real - they prove that it all happened, god is real." Excuse me? That is evidence? By the same logic, we can deduce that Spiderman exist in real life because New York exist.
Events in the bible is not intrinsically linked to god. The wars and destruction, rapes and sacrifices, slavery and etc do not require god to occur. Ever noticed that all sides of a war say god is on their side but only the victorious "really" have god "on their side."
Even if historical evidence reveal that Jesus existed (although it is still highly debatable) but nothing has verified his divinity. The evidence where it really matters, that is Jesus' divinity, is lacking. Where is the extra-biblical evidence? The historians didn't bother writing about any of his miracles?
Canonization of the bible
The process that lead to the canonization of the bible is seemly arbitrary.
Check out a lecture on the history of the biblical canon
(by ACA board member, Matt Dillahunty - former fundamentalist christian)
► Powerpoint slides here
► Audio here
If you're skeptical of the source (and I think you might), then you can read this really long article.
For these reasons, I do not accept any holy book (in particular, the bible) as evidence of god. Furthermore, scripture is still poor evidence for any god even if accepted.
Why I don't believe that there is a god.
The simple answer: No evidence.
Simply put, belief is the acceptance that a proposition is true.
To accept the proposition means to be convinced. And to be convinced, I need evidence.
All too frequently, I'm presented with so-called of evidence
Evidence such as:
► The bible, or whatever holy book
► The universe
► The complexity of life
► The morality of humans
I discount all of those. They are not evidence for god.
When the point of contention is whether or not this being exist or not, you cannot enter his alleged products as evidence. If god does not exist, he cannot be the cause of those products. On top of that, there are naturalistic explanations, backed by evidence, for them.
To claim that god exist, evidence of god manifesting is required. In order to determine if something exist or not, we look for its manifestation.
This table, that my computer is sitting on, exist. I can see it. I can touch it. Basically, it's observable. I can perceive its manifestation.
Gravity exist. If I drop my pen, it will fall to the ground. That is the manifestation of gravity.
What about god? We don't have any evidence that god exist. For example, one of god's alleged manifestation is answering prayers. But yet, we find no statistical significance; god isn't answering them - he's doing no better than chance.
My basic stance on belief is this: Belief is not warranted unless sufficient evidence is presented. Since no evidence has been found, the proposition that god exist is not demonstrably true. Belief is not warranted so I hold the default position: disbelief.
Evidence is important for one simple reason; They demonstrate conformity to reality. If you care whether your beliefs are true or not, you must have evidence to back your beliefs. If you just "have faith" and disregard evidence contrary to your beliefs, you don't care about conformity to reality - you believe because you believe because you want to believe.
In the future, I'll touch on the other so-called evidence & arguments for god's existence and explain why I discount them as well.
The Argument from Scripture
► The bible (or any other holy book) as poor evidence
► A consideration of the origins of the "great" monotheistic faiths
► Yahweh as a god unworthy of worship even if he existed
The Argument from Design
► Abiogenesis, life and gods
► The Argument from Personal Incredulity
► Evolution and its denial
► Fine Tuned Universe
The Argument from Morality
► Morals as a product of humanity not of divinity
The First Cause Argument
► Special pleading - The universe vs. god